Training with a Purpose: Kelly Kraegel’s Philosophy on Developing Horsemen Over Champions

What Happened

Kelly Kraegel, owner and head trainer of Cottonwood Creek Ranch in Oklahoma City, is gaining national attention for HER methodology in developing both world-class show horses and the next generation of professional horsemen. Transitioning from a childhood with no equestrian background to becoming a three-time Horse World People’s Choice Instructor of the Year, Kraegel has built a program centered on "training with a purpose."

Kraegel’s approach focuses on the "why" behind the "how." By ensuring riders understand the mechanics and psychology of their horses, she transitions them from simply following instructions to making independent, sound decisions in the saddle. This philosophy has proven successful across multiple breeds and disciplines; notably, in 2016, Kraegel became the first professional to train both the American Saddlebred (ASB) Open Western Pleasure World Grand Champion and the Morgan Open Western Pleasure World Champion in the same year.

Why It Matters

In an industry often critiqued for focusing on ribbons over foundational skills, Kraegel’s success underscores the long-term value of horsemanship-first coaching. For riders and parents, this model suggests that a supportive "barn family" environment and a deep understanding of equine behavior are not just supplementary to winning, they are the catalyst for it.

Furthermore, Kraegel’s program serves as a blueprint for professional development. By mentoring former students like Ryne Swope (now co-owner of Cobalt Stables) and Madi Fitzgerald DeBee (Cottonwood’s lesson program manager), she is actively addressing the industry's need for skilled, kind, and methodical professionals. Her story also highlights the accessibility of the sport, tracing her path from handmade show clothes and neighborhood pony rides to the top tier of the Morgan and Saddlebred worlds.

Discipline Context

Kraegel’s work primarily impacts the Morgan and American Saddlebred communities, specifically within the Western Pleasure and Saddle Seat disciplines. However, her emphasis on tailored communication, using everything from video analysis to physical demonstrations, is a relevant model for trainers across all disciplines, including Western Dressage and youth equitation. Her program emphasizes that "great horsemen" are the foundation upon which "champions" are built, regardless of the specific seat or breed.

Quick Facts

• Trainer: Kelly Kraegel
• Facility: Cottonwood Creek Ranch, Oklahoma City, OK
• Key Breeds: Morgan, American Saddlebred
• Major Achievement: First professional to train ASB and Morgan Open Western Pleasure World Champions in the same year (2016).
• Recognitions: Three-time Horse World People’s Choice Instructor of the Year (2011, 2013, 2014).
• Notable Proteges: Ryne Swope (Cobalt Stables), Madi Fitzgerald DeBee (Cottonwood Creek Ranch).

Riders who want to talk this through with others can join TurnoutHQ community groups.